From the September 2008 CBE Bulletin
This summer, for the second year in a row, my
family spent July in Jerusalem, where I was one of four faculty members for a
teen program called Bronfman Youth Fellows in Israel. In its twenty-second
year, BYFI was started during an era of American Jewish life when Jews from
across the denominational divide rarely spoke or interacted in a meaningful way
with regards to questions about and approaches to Torah, Prayer and Mitzvot.
With extraordinary vision, the philanthropist Edgar Bronfman recognized there
was more that united than divided us as a people and made the strategic
decision to focus on 26 remarkable 17 year olds from diverse backgrounds who
could seed the ground for a future generation to build community. The program has
produced great writers, lawyers, activists, rabbis and cantors—all of whom
credit the program with opening their eyes to a broader Jewish world in Israel
and beyond.
For five weeks, I worked with
Orthodox, Conservative and Reconstructionist rabbis –each of us teaching for 90
minutes every morning before together venturing out in Jerusalem, Tel Aviv, the
North and the South, and engaging in the vast array of issues that face
Israelis, Palestinians, and world Jewry. We met leading writers like Etgar
Keret and AB Yehoshua, Knesset Members and Government Ministers like Michael
Melchior, peace activists from the Will Brandt Center for Coexistence, the
Belzer Hasidim Synagogue
and the Jerusalem Open House for the city’s Jewish and Arab LGBT population.
And that was just one week! Reform kids tried Orthodox shuls and Orthodox kids
tried Reform shuls—each learning that the Jewish people are united by a love of
tradition, language and learning, the land and the narrative of their common
peoplehood that is changing, dynamic, and a source of inspiration for growth.
We crossed paths with birthright trips, congregants and friends visiting Israel—including
Hannah Gorfinkel on her NFTY trip, Nikki DeBlosi on her first year at HUC, and
David Greenberg and Abby Everett studying Hebrew diligently up at Haifa
University. Like New York, Israel is the other crossroads of Jewish peoplehood.
What a gift to be able to experience it.
Upon our arrival, there was a new and unique
terrorist attack by tractor; another would come two weeks later. With the
security fence impeding most suicide bombers, now the terror threat comes from
East Jerusalem, complicating the delicate infrastructure of Jerusalem's
inhabitants, further muddying the potential waters of peace. The exchange of
the bodies of Ehud Goldwasser and Eldad Regev, killed in Lebanon, for Samir
Kuntar, a Lebanese terrorist who killed an Israeli child with his bare hands,
tore at the heart of the country. Soon after, Prime Minister Ehud Olmert
announced he would not seek re-election, throwing electoral politics into
disarray. And as those of you who have visited Israel know, each hour the radio
news would play—this summer with the added tension of literally one hour
updates on the state of affairs with Iran and its development of nuclear
weapons. On one hand, tension was very high…
And yet, the Shekel is stronger
than the dollar and news carried story after story of American, European, and
Chinese investment in Israel's booming economy. The Israel Museum celebrated
the country's 60th anniversary with a moving and provocative exhibit of Israeli
art that demonstrates a society alert to its challenges and alive with the
dilemmas of what its next steps may be. Jerusalem is growing with building and
construction and Tel Aviv now has some of the best restaurants, ice cream, and
chocolate of anywhere in Europe or the US. The papers reported each day of
Israel leading the way in green technological development, electric cars, and
advances in medicine and science that outpace most nations.
Despite so many dilemmas
and the seeming threat to its existence, Israel remains an unprecedented
blessing for the Jewish people. This is not to ignore its deeply ingrained
troubles—most fundamentally the occupied territories, the fate of Palestinians,
and the relationship between the Ultra-Religious and the Secular. But with eyes
wide open, there is a fundamental coming to terms with the fullness of Jewish
life that is undeniable and something each of us should try to
experience at least once in our lifetime. It's important to remember that
Israel is now home to the greatest number of Jews in the world, exceeding even
New York. What that means for us now and for the future is being determined
there on a daily basis; a totally exhilarating experience.
As congregants of one of New York
city's most vibrant and active synagogues, we have much to learn from and much
to offer our brothers and sisters in Israel. The same values that animate life
at Congregation Beth Elohim, (language, arts and culture, politics and
religious expression; social justice, learning, caring and the environment)
also animate the daily fabric of life in Israel. The great joy in experiencing
both is in seeing and knowing the ways that one informs the other—not unlike
the values of the program that I was privileged to teach on this summer.
On our last night, we took the
kids out for dinner on Rothschild Street in Tel Aviv. Built by many of the
German Jews who left Europe in the first decades of the twentieth century, they
recreated a European city-by-the-sea. After decades of neglect and disrepair,
the world’s largest collection of Bauhaus architecture is being reclaimed,
renovated, and made to shine again, much like our own Temple House at home. At
11 pm at night, with the moon bright in the sky, we all walked slowly back to
the car for the ride to Jerusalem to prepare for our return to Brooklyn. This
first Hebrew modern city, built in 1908, was just waking up, not unlike the
city we would soon fly back to. And we were already discussing what Brooklyn
can learn from Tel Aviv and what Tel Aviv can learn from Brooklyn. After all, in the 1970s, one wave of
immigrants to Park Slope reclaimed the Brownstones and made Beth Elohim their
home, in dialogue with the generation that built the Temple House in the 1930s
and 1940s, who were in dialogue with a generation that made Brooklyn their home
in the 1950s and 1960s. And so it is again, as Brooklyn's growth and renewal
continues, with those having moved here in the 1990s and at the dawn of the
21st century—each with their dreams of the future, born in their understanding
of the past.
If there's one thing these summers have taught me about these two crossroads of
Jewish peoplehood, is that there is more in what unites us than in what divides
us. That with a commitment to grow and dream we can see our way through our
troubles; and when all else fails, we sing, celebrate, share the best parts of ourselves,
lighting the way for each other out of any darkness we may know.
|